MLS Week In Review
Week 3 – ending April 13, 2008
Overview
The referee teams provided for safe and entertaining games. There
were many fantastic goals and, for the most part, games were played in
a competitive environment that was orchestrated by the team of officials. There
were 3 penalty kicks that were deservedly awarded and converted. In
addition, we saw another advantage result in a goal!
Our Office still has a concern over offside decisions. Once again,
there were several instances of players being called offside who were
onside when the ball was played. This included instances where
2 players are moving for the ball but the onside player actually plays
the ball. Clips highlighting this area of work are noted below. We
cannot stress enough: HOLD YOUR FLAG UNTIL YOU ARE CERTAIN
WHO WILL PLAY THE BALL and KEEP THE FLAG DOWN IN SITUATIONS WHERE OFFSIDE
POSITION IS NOT CLEAR CUT! THERE HAVE NOT BEEN ANY INSTANCES
OF DISPUTED GOALS FROM NOT CALLING OFFSIDE.
Week 3 Focus
Referees using personality to “PREVENT
THE NEXT FOUL.” Referees must use personality (not just
blowing the whistle or waving “play on”) to deal with borderline
fouls. The referee’s actions must be visual and send a
message.
Result: There were a few visual examples of this. However,
there were many more instances in which the referee had the opportunity
to use his personality to manage the game and put his mark on the game. In
reviewing the games, it is possible that up to 5 yellow cards were a
bit harsh and that misconduct could have been managed by addressing the
player, face-to-face, and keeping the card in the pocket. REMEMBER,
calculated risk taking. Have confidence in your ability and personality. If
the game is under control and the players are responding, find alternative,
creative means versus cards. That’s not to say you can use
personality as an excuse for failing to deal with a cardable situation.
- Video
Clip 1: New England at Kansas City (43:55). The
referee calls 2 players over to talk with each after they had words. This
type of communication is not always easy but it diffuses and sends
a positive message. Ensure that, as referee, you isolate the
players and look them in the eye. Note, the referee needs to
get to the foul sooner. Look at the score, anticipate that the
winning team will attempt to slow the restart.
- Video
Clip 2: Chicago at San Jose (1:00). This is the
first foul of the game. See how the referee sprints to the spot
and makes the foul seem “larger than it really is.” The
referee then calls the San Jose player over to have a word. This
is the type of management skills that the game needs more of. It
sets the tone and sets it early.
Weekly Commentary
- Offside Decisions: There were many close decisions in which
the Assistant Referee (AR) kept the flag down or waited until the offside
player “played the ball.” These type of decisions
are critical to (as MLS puts it): “free flowing, attacking
soccer.”
- Video
Clip 3: Chicago at San Jose (86:25). AR2 holds
the flag on a situation in-close to goal. Two attackers (one
onside position and one offside) have the opportunity to play the ball. You
can see in the video that the AR exhibits patience and HOLDS the flag
until the offside positioned player actually plays the ball. Great
job showing RESTRAINT.
- Video
Clip 4: Colorado at New England (26:40). Two attacking
players are moving for the ball. However, the onside player actually
plays the ball while the player positioned offside pulls away and,
therefore, does NOT gain an advantage by being in the offside position. A
quick flag is NOT needed. When more than one player has the opportunity
to play a ball and that player is onside at the time his teammate plays
the ball, the AR must show patience and await the outcome – unless
a potential collision may occur. The following is from the AR’s
self-evaluation which was very well written:
Mansally is in the offside position and I am even with the 2nd last
defender when the ball is played and start shuffling down the field
to be even with the ball. I see Cristman heading towards the ball as
well. As the ball lands I saw it touch Mansally. After
reviewing the situation from the angle of the TV it does not touch him and
I should have left the flag down and let it go. I have to have better
concentration on this situation and closely look at where the ball lands
and the position of the player it is landing near as well as the distance
to his teammate. The defender hesitates as he sees it landing as well. But
that should not matter. I should have left it down.
- Video
Clip 5: NY at Dallas (65:40). Dallas gets a breakaway
on a close offside. Keeping the flag down results in a GOAL. This
was not an easy call as the attacker is running diagonally and there
are several defenders spread-out across the field. Patience pays
dividends and AR2 should be applauded for allowing play to continue.
- Video
Clip 6: Chivas at Columbus (56:25). The attacker
is flagged for being offside but the replay shows that the situation
is close enough to warrant keeping the flag down. If it is not
CLEARLY OFFSIDE, give the benefit to attacking soccer.
- Video
Clip 7: Toronto at Galaxy (36:30). There are 2
players who have the potential to play the ball. This is an important
indication for the AR – restraint is needed when more than 1
player can get the ball. Look at the actions of the offside attacker. Knowing
he is offside, he stops his run and the onside attacker runs through. ARs
must have a wide peripheral perspective and know that there is the
possibility of another player becoming involved. In this case,
the AR is square to the field so he should have the wider view. Patience. Sometimes
the obvious is not so obvious.
- AR Involvement and Teamwork: Last week, the topic of “over-involvement
by ARs” was addressed. Keys were:
- Does the referee have a clear view of the offense?
- Does the referee need me?
- Give the referee first crack at the foul.
- If the referee team does not call it, will game control be impacted
negatively?
- Will a team gain an unfair advantage if we don’t make the call?
There were some incidents from which we can continue to learn as they
relate to ARs participating in game control. This is a mindset
issue and an issue in which ARs must put more trust in the referees,
especially the experienced referees. In the clips below, look who
the referee is and ask yourself, “Did the referee and the game
need my flag?”
- Video
Clip 8: NY at Dallas (52:00). This is an exceptional
piece of teamwork. This is BIG TIME work by the AR, referee,
and 4th official. Watch how the referee, AR, and 4th work as
a unit to prevent escalation. THIS IS REFEREEING! Look also
how the referee immediately gets the yellow card out to show everyone
he is taking action. The action on the part of the referee
team probably saves the Dallas player from being booked for misconduct
also. Did the referee need the ARs assistance? Yes. If
the referee team does not make the call, will game control be negatively
affected? Yes. So, ARs and 4th officials, be INVOLVED in this
one!
- Video
Clip 9: Chicago at San Jose (32:25). In this
case, the AR flags a foul that is not needed for the game (game is
well in control and it is a trifling foul). The referee is
well positioned to see the action and, actually, has waved “play-on.” The
referee is empowered to wave off these type of flags but the best
solution is for the AR to leave it to the referee. ARs must
FEEL THE GAME as the referee is feeling the game.
- Video
Clip 10: Chicago at San Jose (40:05). The foul
decision by the AR is over-ruled by the referee. The referee
has a clear line of vision to the foul and the defender has the inside
position. These type of decisions can lead to player frustration
and to eventual yellow cards for dissent.
- Video
Clip 11: Chicago at San Jose (83:00). The ARs
flag comes up well after the referee’s whistle. Question:
why so long for the flag? Assistance is good here but it must
be timely. No need for the flag if it comes after the whistle.
- Penalty Kick Decisions: There were 2 correctly awarded penalty
kicks this past weekend
- Video
Clip 12: Chivas at Columbus (23:55). This involves
a penalty that is awarded against a defender who initiates the foul
(shirt pull) outside the penalty area but continues the foul inside
the area. Pursuant to the direction at National Camp and the
April 30, 2007 memorandum (“When Fouls Continue”) this
is a correct and courageous decision. Although the majority of
the foul occurs outside the penalty area, the referee must award the
decision that is most advantageous to the attacker. In this case,
a penalty kick. Note the referee had to have excellent position
to see this. ARs should be prepared to provide the inside or
outside the area signal to assist the referee.
- Video
Clip 13 and Video
Clip 14: New England at Kansas City
(26:18). Clip 13 shows a clear penalty and the referee is well
positioned to see that the foul occurs inside the penalty area. Optimum
would have been for the referee to delay the whistle and await the
outcome of the shot on goal. Due to the short nature of time
between the foul and the shot, the referee reserves the right to come
back and award the penalty kick should the shot miss. In this
case, the whistle came a bit early. Use that extra time given
to you by the Laws of the Game to your advantage. Compare this
clip to Clip 14. In the second case, the referee awaits the outcome
of the play and seeing that the attacking team will not have an advantage,
the referee correctly comes back to the original foul and signals a
penalty kick. Excellent use of timing and holding the whistle to see
if a positive outcome will occur. Referee to the “Advantage
in the Penalty Area” memo distributed April 11, 2008 from our
office.
- Game Disrepute and Dissent: Actions by players that bring the
game into disrepute and/or show dissent (in particular, visual dissent)
must be dealt with. This is not the family environment we want
nor MLS wants exhibited in the games. It is critical to deal with players
that make “their presence known” by injecting themselves
into situations that they were not originally involved. Please
deal with these type of situations in an appropriate manner based upon
the game.
- Video
Clip 15: Chicago at San Jose (53:40). In this situation,
the referee correctly cautions the player who came from approximately
25 yards to engage with opponents. This is the type of situation
that, if not dealt with appropriately, can lead to future problems
in the game.
- Denying an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity (DOGSO): A foul
is a foul regardless of who commits it. MLS is a fast-paced game
with lots of counter attacks. Consequently, referees and ARs
can anticipate many a chance to make decisions relating to DOGSO. Positioning
and fitness levels must be commensurate with this style of play. Clips
will show 2 different opportunities for the referee to deal with DOGSO. In
the second clip, the referee read the play correctly and decided any
contact was incidental. When evaluating the following 2 clips,
REMEMBER, every fair challenge, with contact, is not a foul.
- Video
Clip 16: Toronto at Galaxy (69:40). The Toronto
attacker is clearly behind the defense and in possession of the ball. The
Galaxy defender, knowing he is beat, grabs the arm of the attacker. This
foul is made with the hand/arm. The referee must recognize the
tactical nature of the offense and “feel” the speed of
play. Based upon the speed, it does not take much to knock the
attacker off the ball. This is DOGSO and a red card must be issued. The
following is a quote from Galaxy head coach Ruud Gullit: "I
think we were lucky there. It was the only luck we had the whole
game."
- Video
Clip 17: Chicago at San Jose (52:23). The attacker
is moving to goal with speed and is behind the defense. However,
the defender catches up and the attacker loses possession of the ball
on a fair body challenge. Both players are using their body but
not with undo force. It is a matter of the defender’s speed surpassing
that of the attacker. A no foul call is appropriate. Well
done and a good feel for the situation is exhibited by the referee.
- Wall Management and Delaying the Restart: There are many talented
free kick specialists now playing in MLS. Hence, the “red
zone” becomes even more critical. Defending teams want
to take away any advantage the kicker may have. Get 10 yards and maintain
10 yards. Additionally, referees must be cognizant of the score
and the time in the match. Teams leading, will “push the
envelop” and test the referee to see if they can slow the opposing
restarts down. We must deal with these two scenarios by being
active and having a presence around the ball/situation.
- Video
Clip 18: New England at Kansas City (43:45): The
referee makes a solid foul decision. New England is ahead 3-1;
hence, every second that ticks off the clock is to their advantage. The
referee must be aware of this. Earlier actions by defending players
send messages that must resonate with the referee. Once we are
aware, we can then take action to prevent the delay. The
referee should sprint to the spot of the foul and ensure the defender’s
opportunity to interpose himself in front of the ball is minimized. Once
New England has delayed, the referee’s use of personality to
address the two players is fantastic.
- Video
Clip 19: Toronto at Galaxy (46:00). Wall management
will become increasingly important and critical since over 30% of goals
are scored from restarts. Referees must reduce the time the ball
is out of play, get a FULL 10 yards, and ensure no one advances to
block the kick (not permit free kick interference). If a player
advances and makes contact with the ball, the referee is empowered
to retake the kick without having to caution the player but allow the
team the opportunity that they earned. Note, in this clip, it
takes 1:40 from foul to the taking of the free kick.
- Elbow on Restarts: Over the past several years, there have
been increasing incidents of elbows on restart services into the penalty
area. These all have similar characteristics: (a) They
are long services; (b) Attacking players are attempting to move into
an advantageous position; and (c) Defenders attempt to disguise the
elbow as a forearm to the opponent’s chest as a normal run of
play. Referees, ARs, and 4th officials must be prepared. On
the long services, focus should be on the group of players and not
on the ball. ARs must be given the leeway to intervene. 4th
officials should move slightly down the midline to view the collection
of players. Referees need to position themselves so that their
main focus is on where the ball will land yet manage the ball with
peripheral vision.
- Video
Clip 20: New England at Kansas City (47:15). Unfortunate
for the referee team, an elbow to the head of the opponent went unnoticed. Note
the referee’s position. A more advantageous position would
be at the top of the penalty are near the arc. From this vantage
point, the referee’s primary focus can be on the players and
where the ball will land. While the ball is in flight, the referee
will not have as many players potentially in his line of sight. Peripheral
vision can manage the ball and players surrounding the ball. The
referee’s primary focus should be on the target area for the
ball and not on the restart. The AR should feel obligated to
participate in this decision if the AR sees the defender’s actions.
- Tactical Foul Requiring Yellow Card: Due to the speed of the
MLS game, defending players must find multiple methods to slow attacking
play and prevent the progress of not only the ball but also of attacking
players who may advance into space behind them, unmarked. Consequently,
fouls like holding off the ball are prevalent and must be addressed
by the referee.
- Video
Clip 21: DC at Real Salt Lake (43:20). This is
a clear case where the defender knows the attacker will get behind
him, into the space. This is a tactical foul intended to destroy
attacking play. Hence, a yellow card must be issued. Note
that the referee seems to be spending more time dealing with the player
fouled than the player committing the offense.
- Stoppage Time: Announcements are made in each stadium that
the time indicated by the 4th official is the MINIMUM amount of extended
time. Consequently, if a referee indicates 3 minutes, no less
than 3 minutes can be played. The referee can use discretion
and add more time but this should be managed in way, that if all possible,
the teams are made aware of the added time. Referees should coordinate
the appropriate signals with the 4th official prior to the game.
9. Fourth Official / Substitution Board: Many of the games
are played in daylight. The substitution board is for the spectators,
television, and players. Therefore, the 4th official should make
certain that the “flip boards” are available and utilized
in bright light. Television, in particular, likes to make a live
shot of the board when the 4th official indicates stoppage time.
Week 4 Focus
Assistant referees continuing to exhibit patience
in decision making. Focus on holding the flag and on giving the
referee first crack at calls. Get the offside calls correct,
first and foremost. All other involvement is secondary.
Summary
Officials’ hard work over the first few weeks of the season has
paid dividends. Dividends in terms of entertaining and attacking
soccer, void of excessive fouling but filled with an abundance of superb
goals. With continued focus on offside decisions and smart game
flow, you can continue to make further inroads into improving the product
on the field.
Statistics prove your hard work is paying off. There were an average
of 2.86 goals per game this week. We whistled an average of 25
fouls per game. This is up from last week’s average of 23
fouls a game but still significantly less that a year ago.
This is from MLS:
Goals Galore in Week 3; Goal Scoring Up Through Third Week of
the Season
There were 24 goals scored in Week 3 of the 2008 MLS Season and through
21 games a total of 67 goals have been scored for an average of 3.19
goals per game. That total is up from 55 goals (2.39 average) at
a similar point last year. There has been only one scoreless game in
2008. Shaky defense or stellar offense? Three goalkeepers – Jon
Busch, Bouna Coundoul and Jon Conway – each have two shutouts on
the season, but free flowing, attacking soccer has dominated in the
early going. |